Getting Reviews in Trade Journals

A powerful thing you can do to garner attention for your book is to receive reviews in publishing trade journals, in addition to traditional publications such as newspapers, magazines, and high-profile websites. These reviews can also go a long way in convincing bookstores and libraries to stock your book, and it creates a kind of marketing ripple effect by adding a stamp of approval that other outlets will see. Even if you don’t receive a 100% gushing review, there will usually be at least a positive sentence or two you can use as a blurb on your sell sheet, pitch letters, website, Amazon listing, and other promotional communication.

Reviews from professional trade publications like Kirkus and Publishers Weekly are powerful when it comes to distribution in bookstores and libraries, and for any kind of publicity pitching. As you know, the world of self-published and indie-published books is vast and encompasses huge variations in quality, so a professional review can really make your book stand out from the pack. Other publications like newspapers and high-profile websites are definitely more likely to consider reviewing your book if they see you have a blurb from a professional source. It probably doesn’t make as big a difference for consumers, since most folks have no idea who Kirkus and PW are, but it can be very effective for garnering attention from bigger platforms.

The downside, of course, is you often have to pay for these reviews (Kirkus starts at $450; PW starts at $399) and there is a several week lead time (though you can pay extra for expedited reviews). One upside is that you can choose to keep the review private if it is not positive. Most of these publications also have the option of automatically adding the review to your book’s metadata across several platforms. Others you may want to look into are Foreword Magazine and the Independent Book Review, which only review indie and self-published books. 

For authors who are taking a more passive marketing/publicity approach and are primarily focused on selling their book on Amazon, this investment might not be worth it. But for authors who want to put a lot of effort into building their platform by getting booked on podcasts or other media, getting invited to speak at conferences, getting reviewed in newspapers and other mainstream platforms, or getting their book into bookstores and libraries, I’d say it’s definitely a good investment. 

While trade journals such as Kirkus do charge a fee for reviews, traditional publications such as newspapers do not. However, newspapers will often be more likely to give you attention if you already have a positive review from a trade journal. 

You may submit your book for reviews yourself, or we are also happy to manage the process for you. Just let us know!

Top places to get professional reviews:

*we may be able to get discounts on some of these as IBPA members

Kirkus: reviews starting at $450; 7–9 week lead time.

You can choose to publish it for free on KirkusReviews.com, or you can keep it private if it’s a negative review. 

BookLife (fee-based service of Publisher’s Weekly): reviews starting at $399; 6 weeks lead time.

You have the option of approving your review to run in an upcoming issue of Publishers Weekly and addition to your book’s metadata across several seller platforms. There is also the option to submit your book for consideration for a free review by Publisher’s Weekly (bypassing the paid service), but they rarely accept self-published books. 

Clarion (fee-based service of Foreword Magazine): $549; 4–6 weeks lead time.

Foreword is a journal devoted entirely to independently published books and goes out to indie booksellers, B&N’s small press department, and librarians. Great if you want to get the attention of physical bookstores and libraries. With your approval, your review will be posted on their high traffic website and licensed to book wholesalers. 

Foreword Magazine: free but competitive; must be submitted at least 4 months before pub date.

If your book is not selected, you still have the option of paying for a Clarion review.

Booklist (American Library Association): no fee, but highly competitive for self-published books; must be submitted at least 15 weeks prior to publication.

Blue Ink Review (fee-based review partner of Booklist): starting at $445, 7–9 weeks lead time.

Review service specifically for self-published authors. Review will be distributed to Ingram and possible other platforms. 

Library Journal: no fee, but highly competitive for self-published books; must receive books 6 months prior to publication.

Primarily librarian audience.

Independent Book Review: can submit for free review or buy guaranteed review starting at $135; between 1–5 week lead time, depending on fee.

Only reviews independently published books, so reviews are likely to be more positive than outlets that favor traditional publishers.

For Children’s Books:

School Library Journal: same as Library Journal, no fee, but highly competitive for self-published books; must receive books 6 months prior to publication.

Primarily K–12 school librarian audience.

Publisher’s Weekly Children’s: Operates under the same umbrella as Publisher’s Weekly and its paid review service Booklife (see above)

The Horn Book: bi-monthly magazine focused on children’s literature. Accepts submissions via email. 

Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books: does not accept submissions by self-published authors